Super Cities №220—Why Picket Fences Are Under Attack

Brendan Hart

The symbol of the American Dream – picket fences surrounding white houses – are children of the battlefield. The sharpened wood logs would shield archers from advancing cavalry. Many men owe their lives to pickets.

When America began its vast home-building project – fueled by government-backed mortgages for returning GIs from World War II – pickets received a nice commercial upgrade. Instead of goring horses on European battlefields, Braveheart-style, pickets came to symbolize and protect the It's a Wonderful Life version of the American Dream.

But there's a big problem with pickets. They are anti-capitalist.

The things they protect – single-family homes and yards – have created a housing crisis in many American cities. American cities have become the lands of single-family, picket-protected zones. Cities by percentages of land zoned for single-family homes:

  • San Jose, California – 94%
  • Arlington, Texas – 89%
  • Charlotte, North Carolina – 84%
  • Seattle, Washington – 81%
  • Portland, Oregon – 77%
  • Los Angeles, California – 75%
  • Minneapolis, Minnesota – 70%

Zoning has a fraught history in American cities. Originally intended to protect homeowners from mass industrialization, zoning became a tool to regulate where and how people could live. For much of America's history, zoning was a legal way for policymakers – backed by real estate developers who knew they would make more money in zoned areas – to separate communities along racial, ethnic, and religious lines.

Now the pitchforks are out for pickets and the thing they represent.

California is on the verge of eliminating single-family zoning throughout the state. Minneapolis outlawed single-family development, but not all residents are happy about it. Oregon is eliminating single-family construction because "the crux of the matter is land is the scarce commodity here."

Outlawing single-family zoning is not a silver bullet the housing crisis. New York City is 15% zoned for single-family homes, but its cost of living is among the highest in the world.

Fortunately, we can rely on old friends: supply and demand. As a Harvard economist states, "Simply put, the places that are expensive don't build a lot, and the places that build a lot aren't expensive."

Picket fences – and all they represent – are just another example of the two forms of American capitalism.

You've successfully subscribed to Super Cities
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
Great! You've successfully signed up.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all content.